A federal appeals court on Monday declined an urgent request from the Justice Department to force California to segregate roughly 20,000 mail-in ballots tied to a Trump administration lawsuit. The California voting case centers around allegations that the state failed to properly review a list of individuals claimed to be potential non-citizens ahead of the midterm election.
Appeals Court Rejects DOJ Request
In a 2-1 decision, a panel from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals determined that the court lacked jurisdiction at this specific stage of the litigation. The panel's ruling sent the matter back down to the district court, which scheduled a hearing for Tuesday afternoon regarding the underlying DOJ lawsuit.
The majority opinion was issued by Circuit Judge Mark Bennett, an appointee of President Donald Trump, and Circuit Judge Gabriel Sanchez, an appointee of President Joe Biden. Circuit Judge Patrick Bumatay, another Trump appointee, dissented from the decision.
Panel Cites Self-Constructed Emergency
During a rare Sunday emergency hearing, the judicial panel expressed significant skepticism regarding the federal government's push for a rushed appellate ruling. The majority specifically criticized the timing of the legal maneuvers.
In their written opinion, Bennett and Sanchez stated that the government's emergency was partly self-inflicted. The judges pointed to delays by the United States in filing the suit, recognizing state processing schedules, and communicating desired relief to the court.
- DOJ filed a lawsuit earlier this month accusing California of failing to review a list of alleged non-citizens.
- The Trump administration claimed roughly 20,000 individuals on the list were sent mail-in ballots.
- Los Angeles officials analyzed a sample of 200 names from the list.
- Roughly 40% of the sampled individuals indicated they were born in the United States.
- About 71.2% of those sampled records showed no prior voting history.
Constitutional Concerns and Jurisdiction
During oral arguments, Circuit Judge Mark Bennett repeatedly questioned DOJ attorney Matthew Donnelly about whether the appeals court held proper jurisdiction, pointing out that a district judge hearing was already on the calendar for Tuesday. Bennett also raised deep constitutional questions regarding the framework of the lawsuit.
Bennett suggested the legal challenge appeared to run counter to the Constitution's Elections Clause, which grants states authority over how elections are conducted. DOJ attorney Matthew Donnelly countered that California's execution of election administration infringes upon the federal government's authority to enforce federal statutes prohibiting non-citizen voting.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decide?
The 9th Circuit panel voted 2-1 to reject the Justice Department's request for an immediate order to segregate approximately 20,000 mail-in ballots in California, ruling that the appeals court lacked jurisdiction at this stage.
Why did the judges call the emergency self-constructed?
Judges Mark Bennett and Gabriel Sanchez wrote that the delay was attributable to the United States waiting to file the suit, failing to initially recognize California's existing election laws and scale, and delaying communication of desired relief.
What did Los Angeles officials find in their analysis of the voter list?
Local officials analyzed a sample of 200 names from the 20,000-person list and found that nearly 40% indicated they were born in the U.S. while 71.2% had no voting history.